Bitcoin’s “death cross” is making the rounds again in conversations and inboxes. Matthew Sigel, VanEck’s head of digital assets research, noted he’s been fielding client questions about this latest occurrence—where the 50-day moving average falls below the 200-day—and responded with a data-heavy reassurance. On X, he called it a “lagging indicator,” sharing a table of every Bitcoin death cross since 2011. The summary is straightforward: the median return six months after a death cross is +30%, jumping to +89% after twelve months, with a positive hit rate of 64%.
But the returns only tell part of the story. The more revealing aspect is Sigel’s “market regime” column, which highlights how the same technical signal can have vastly different implications depending on the market cycle phase.
Look at those labeled as a type of “bottom.” In 2011 (“post-bubble bottom”), the death cross appeared after an early-cycle crash, followed by a 357% gain over the next year. The 2015 “cycle bottom” saw gains of +82% and +159% over six and twelve months, respectively—typical behavior after a market capitulation, where trend indicators lag behind a price recovery. The 2020 “Covid bottom” was the most extreme, with a forced liquidation followed by a massive policy response and an 812% rebound in twelve months. 2023 is also tagged a “cycle bottom,” with gains of +173% and +121%, illustrating crypto’s notorious “awful until it isn’t” turnaround.
Then there’s the “structural bear” regime, seen in 2014 (twice), 2018, and 2022. Here, forward returns were mostly poor: 2014 saw declines of -48% and -56% over twelve months, 2018 was -35%, and 2022 was -52%. This isn’t a quick washout and bounce; it reflects a sustained downtrend driven by systemic deleveraging—whether from miners, credit, exchanges, or broader liquidity tightening. In these periods, the death cross isn’t a late warning but a confirmation of an entrenched downtrend.
The intermediate labels are also telling. 2019 is marked “late bear,” with a choppy +9% at six months but a strong +89% at twelve as the cycle began to turn. 2021 is “late cycle”: a +30% gain at six months turned into a -43% loss at twelve, fitting a period where trend signals become unreliable amid distribution and macro tightening.
Finally, there’s 2024, tagged “post-ETF regime,” with projected gains of +58% and +94% over six and twelve months. This label is significant. It suggests the market backdrop has shifted due to structural demand from ETFs, changes in liquidity dynamics, and a blend of traditional finance flows alongside crypto-native positioning—moving beyond pure reflexive leverage.
The key takeaway isn’t that death crosses are inherently bullish. They’re not. Instead, the signal is largely a trailing reflection of past price action. What truly matters is the underlying market regime—whether it’s a bottoming phase, a late bear market, structural deleveraging, a late cycle, or a post-ETF flow environment. That context determines whether the death cross is a false alarm, a trend confirmation, or simply noise with an ominous name.
At the time of writing, Bitcoin is trading at $86,631.
Frequently Asked Questions
FAQs Bitcoins Death Cross Fear vs Historical Data
Beginner Questions
What is a Death Cross in Bitcoin trading
A Death Cross is a chart pattern that occurs when Bitcoins shortterm moving average crosses below its longterm movingterm average Its seen by some traders as a potential signal for a bearish or downward trend
Why does a Death Cross spark fears
It sparks fear because it has historically been associated with the start of major market downturns in traditional finance The name itself sounds ominous leading investors to worry about significant price drops ahead
What does it mean that historical data suggests it signals a market bottom
This means that when looking back at past Bitcoin markets the appearance of a Death Cross has sometimes coincided with prices being near their lowest point in a cycle rather than being a predictor of a new steep crash It can mark a moment of maximum pessimism before a recovery
Should I sell my Bitcoin if I see a Death Cross
Not necessarily Relying on a single technical indicator is risky Historical data for Bitcoin shows mixed results and selling based solely on this signal could mean selling at a low point if it indeed marks a bottom Its better to consider your longterm strategy and risk tolerance
How often does a Death Cross happen for Bitcoin
Its a relatively rare event typically occurring only a few times during major market cycles which can last several years
Advanced Practical Questions
How reliable is the Death Cross as a predictive indicator for Bitcoin
Its reliability is highly debated In Bitcoins volatile history the signal has been a false alarm as often as it has preceded further decline It is considered a lagging indicator meaning it confirms a trend that has already happened rather than predicting the future with certainty
Can you give an example where a Death Cross signaled a bottom
A notable example was in March 2020 Bitcoin formed a Death Cross during the COVID19 market crash While it created fear the price of Bitcoin found a major bottom shortly after and then began a massive bull run to new alltime highs
What are other indicators I should look at alongside a Death Cross
To get better context analysts also watch